Money & Finance › Commercial real estate lending › When CRE loans go bad: workouts, foreclosure and receivership
Loan modifications and forbearance agreements
· Concept
Fact, law or dataA rule, statute, definition or measured number.
A lender and borrower agree to change a troubled loan's terms (a modification) or to hold off on remedies for a while (forbearance).
See it on the Money & Finance map →How it works
A modification rewrites the loan: a maturity extension, interest-only months, a lower rate, or a split into an A-note that keeps paying and a B-note, a 'hope note' repaid only if value recovers. The lender usually asks for something back: a principal paydown, a cash sweep, new reserves or a fresh guarantee. Forbearance leaves the default in place, but the lender agrees not to foreclose for, say, 6–12 months while the owner sells or re-leases. Borrowers usually sign a release of claims.
Why it matters
Many troubled CRE loans, especially at banks, end in a modification rather than foreclosure, because both sides often recover more by waiting. The terms decide who absorbs the loss.
Facts, rules and data
Modification and forbearance agreements, bank disclosures of modifications to borrowers in financial difficulty (required since 2023), the 2023 interagency workout statement, and CMBS servicer reports.
Debates and risks
Whether repeated extensions ('extend and pretend') save value by giving markets time, or only delay losses and keep weak owners in place, is debated.
Inside this (1)
Connections (6)
▸REMIC: the tax-free trust that holds a CMBS loan pool tightly restricts Loan modifications and forbearance agreementsFact, law or data
The connection
Before trouble, a CMBS servicer generally cannot change a loan's rate, maturity or collateral without risking the trust's tax status. Once default occurs or is 'reasonably foreseeable', it can. That is why borrowers often must ask to move to special servicing, or even stop paying, before talks can start.
When and why
In US CMBS trusts since 1987; IRS Rev. Proc. 2009-45 (September 2009) allowed changes when a servicer sees a significant risk of default.
How we know
Treasury regulation 1.860G-2(b), Rev. Proc. 2009-45, and servicer commentary describing borrowers' requests for transfer.
Debates and risks
Whether the rules push borrowers to default strategically just to open talks is a common complaint that is hard to measure.
▸CMBS master and special servicers negotiate Loan modifications and forbearance agreementsFact, law or data
The connection
Once a loan transfers, the special servicer sends a pre-negotiation letter, orders an appraisal and weighs options: extend the maturity, cut the rate, split the loan into an A-note and a 'hope note', accept a discounted payoff, or foreclose. It picks whatever it expects to recover the most in present value.
When and why
Across CMBS workouts; widely used after 2009 and again for office and retail loans since 2023.
How we know
Servicer commentary in monthly reports, tracked by Trepp and Morningstar Credit, records each modification's terms.
Debates and risks
Whether A/B 'hope note' splits recover more than foreclosure, or only defer losses, is debated.
▸Jamison Properties' CMBS office defaults in Los Angeles (2024–26) won forbearance on some loans through Loan modifications and forbearance agreementsFact, law or data
The connection
Rather than hand back keys, Jamison sought time. 600 South Commonwealth got a one-year extension after its January 2024 maturity, then missed again in 2025. Equitable Plaza and Central Plaza got forbearance agreements; Equitable's was extended so Jamison could line up a refinance, with an October 2026 payoff date.
When and why
Negotiated with special servicers, including LNR, from 2024 through 2026.
How we know
Servicer commentary reported by Morningstar Credit, Commercial Observer (2025) and The Real Deal (July 2026).
Debates and risks
Whether the refinance closed, and on what terms against an appraisal of about $58 million, was not public at last report.
▸Loan modifications and forbearance agreements are the main alternative to Commercial foreclosure: trustee's sales and judicial foreclosureFact, law or data
The connection
Foreclosure is slow and costly, and leaves the lender owning a building it must run and sell, often at a discount. A modification, such as an extension with a paydown, can recover more if the building stabilizes. Lenders compare the expected recovery from a modified loan with the net proceeds of foreclosure.
When and why
In US bank and CMBS workouts; CMBS special servicers must choose the option with the higher net present value for bondholders.
How we know
CMBS pooling and servicing agreements, the 2023 interagency workout statement, and servicer reports on resolutions.
Debates and risks
Whether modifications cut final losses or mostly delay foreclosures is debated; studies of earlier cycles found many modified loans defaulted again.
▸Interagency CRE loan workout policy statement (2009, updated 2023) encourages prudent Loan modifications and forbearance agreementsFact, law or data
The connection
It tells banks that prudent modifications are acceptable: extending maturity, cutting the rate, adding interest-only periods, or splitting a loan into a performing A note and a deferred B note. In return the bank must underwrite the borrower afresh, and owners are often asked for a paydown, new reserves or a guarantee.
When and why
Banks nationwide used it in 2009–2012, and again from 2023 as office and other CRE loans matured at higher rates.
How we know
The statements' own worked examples, including multiple-note splits, and banks' disclosures of modified CRE loans in call reports and filings.
Debates and risks
How many modified loans later default anyway; data on outcomes by property type are thin and scattered.
▸Loan modifications and forbearance agreements are the first tool in When CRE loans go bad: workouts, foreclosure and receivershipFact, law or data
The connection
When a loan gets into trouble, the first step is usually talks: a pre-negotiation letter, then a forbearance or modification, before receivers or foreclosure. Banks holding their own loans can modify quickly; CMBS loans must go to a special servicer, which works within the bond trust's tax limits.
When and why
In US commercial lending, widely used since 2023 and encouraged by the regulators' June 2023 policy statement on CRE workouts.
How we know
Bank disclosures of loan modifications, CMBS servicer reports, and the interagency policy statement itself.
Debates and risks
How many troubled loans are being 'extended and pretended' rather than truly resolved is unknown.