Bible & Christianity › The apostles & the New Testament › Pentecost: the Holy Spirit and the first church
Simon Peter, leader of the apostles
died in Rome c. AD 64–68· Person· People
Mostly agreed by scholarsMost historians agree; some details uncertain.
Simon, a Galilean fisherman whom Jesus nicknamed Peter ('rock'), became the leading apostle and, tradition says, died a martyr in Rome.
See it on the Bible & Christianity map →What it is
The Gospels tell how Jesus calls Simon from his nets at Capernaum and names him Cephas, Aramaic for 'rock' (Petros in Greek). He declares Jesus the Messiah, yet denies knowing him three times on the night of the arrest (Mark 14:66–72). After Easter he leads the Jerusalem church, preaches at Pentecost and baptizes the first Gentile convert, the Roman officer Cornelius (Acts 10). Paul calls him a 'pillar' (Galatians 2:9).
Why it matters
Catholics see him as the first pope, citing 'on this rock I will build my church' (Matthew 16:18). Orthodox and Protestants honor him but reject that papal reading, a dispute behind the Great Schism.
Life, legacy and sources
Paul's letters, written in Peter's lifetime, confirm his leadership. His death in Rome is early tradition: 1 Clement (about AD 96) mentions his martyrdom and Ignatius (about 110) links him with Rome.
Questions and debates
Whether Peter was ever 'bishop' of Rome in a formal sense, and whether the bones Pope Paul VI announced as his in 1968 really are, is still debated.
Connections (4)
▸The Twelve Apostles were led by Simon Peter, leader of the apostlesMostly agreed by scholars
The connection
Peter heads every list of the Twelve (Mark 3:16) and often speaks for them: he declares Jesus the Messiah, and with James and John forms an inner circle at the Transfiguration and in Gethsemane. After Easter he leads the group, proposing a replacement for Judas (Acts 1:15–26).
When and where
Galilee and Jerusalem, about AD 28–33; Acts 1–12 shows him leading the church in its first decade.
How do we know?
The Gospels, Acts and Paul's letters agree on his prominence; Paul stayed with 'Cephas' in Jerusalem for 15 days (Galatians 1:18).
Questions and debates
Whether his leadership was a formal office or personal standing matters for the papacy debate. Later, James seems to take the lead in Jerusalem (Galatians 2:12; Acts 15).
▸Simon Peter, leader of the apostles preached the first sermon at Pentecost: the Holy Spirit and the first churchFaith & scripture
The connection
When onlookers at Pentecost said the apostles were drunk, Peter stood up and preached: it was only nine in the morning; this was the outpouring of the Spirit promised by the prophet Joel; and God had raised Jesus, whom they had crucified. About 3,000 were baptized (Acts 2:14–41).
When and where
Jerusalem, at Shavuot, 50 days after Passover, about AD 30 or 33; recorded in Acts 2.
How do we know?
Only Acts records the sermon. Most scholars think Luke composed the speech in his own style, as ancient historians did, while keeping early themes.
Questions and debates
Some doubt the 3,000 figure is literal; estimates of Jerusalem's population then vary widely, though festival pilgrims swelled it.
▸Simon Peter, leader of the apostles is honored by Catholics as founder of The papacy: the popes and medieval ChristendomFaith & scripture
The connection
Catholics point to Jesus's words, 'You are Peter, and on this rock I will build my church... I will give you the keys of the kingdom' (Matthew 16:18–19). By early tradition Peter died in Rome, whose bishops claim his authority. Orthodox and Protestants honor Peter's leadership but read 'the rock' as his faith, or deny a line of supreme authority.
When and where
Matthew 16, set at Caesarea Philippi; Peter's death in Rome around AD 64–68; the claim was pressed by popes like Leo I (440–461).
How do we know?
Early tradition that Peter died in Rome is strong (1 Clement, c. 96). Digs under St Peter's (1939–1949) found a 2nd-century shrine; whether bones there are his divides scholars.
Questions and debates
Whether Matthew 16 implies successors, and how early Rome's bishops claimed authority over other churches, are debated; Rome's bishop Victor I (c. 190) already tried to impose its Easter date on Asian churches.
▸Simon Peter, leader of the apostles was martyred, tradition says, in Roman persecution of ChristiansMostly agreed by scholars
The connection
Early tradition says Peter came to Rome and was killed in Nero's persecution after the fire of AD 64. Origen (about 230), quoted by Eusebius, says he was crucified head-down at his own request; Jerome later added that he felt unworthy to die as Jesus did. John 21:18–19 already hints at the death by which he would 'glorify God'.
When and where
Rome, about AD 64–68; tradition places his tomb on the Vatican Hill, beneath today's St Peter's Basilica.
How do we know?
No record from the time. 1 Clement (about AD 96) mentions his martyrdom, Ignatius (about 110) links him to Rome, and Gaius, a Roman, around 200 pointed to his 'trophy' on the Vatican.
Questions and debates
A few scholars doubt Peter ever reached Rome. Excavations in the 1940s found a 2nd-century shrine under St Peter's; whether bones found there are his is unproven.