Bible & Christianity › Exodus, Law & the Promised Land › Joshua and the conquest of Canaan
Samuel, last judge and kingmaker
c. 11th century BC; 1 Samuel 1–25· Person· People
Faith & scriptureHeld by believers on faith and scripture; history can neither confirm nor rule it out.
Samuel, prophet and the last of the judges, guided Israel's shift from tribal leaders to kings and anointed both Saul and David.
See it on the Bible & Christianity map →What it is
1 Samuel tells how childless Hannah prays for a son and gives him to serve at the shrine of Shiloh under the priest Eli. God calls the boy by name in the night (1 Samuel 3). Grown, Samuel judges Israel and rallies it against the Philistines. When the elders demand 'a king like all the nations' (8:5), he warns that a king will take their sons, fields and a tenth of their harvests, then anoints Saul anyway.
Why it matters
He stands at the hinge from tribal confederation to monarchy, and sets the pattern of prophets who make, criticize and unmake kings.
Life, legacy and sources
Known only from the Bible, chiefly 1 Samuel, which most scholars think was compiled around 600 BC from older stories. No inscription names him. Shiloh, his boyhood shrine, has been excavated and was a real settlement then.
Questions and debates
1 Samuel both grants kingship and disapproves of it; whether those mixed feelings come from two older sources stitched together is debated.
Connections (3)
▸Time of the Judges (Gideon and others) ended with Samuel, last judge and kingmakerFaith & scripture
The connection
Judges ends in chaos, repeating 'in those days there was no king in Israel; everyone did what was right in his own eyes' (21:25). Samuel is the last of these tribal leaders, judging Israel on a yearly circuit of towns. When his own sons prove corrupt, the elders ask him for a king, closing the era.
When and where
1 Samuel 7–8, at Ramah, Bethel, Gilgal and Mizpah, around 1050 BC by traditional dating.
How do we know?
A literary link: Judges and Samuel belong to the 'Deuteronomistic History' (Deuteronomy to Kings), a connected account most scholars think was edited around 600 BC and in the exile.
Questions and debates
Whether Israel truly passed from a 'judges' era to kingship, or the books impose a tidy sequence on overlapping local leaders, is debated.
▸Samuel, last judge and kingmaker anointed King Saul, Israel's first kingFaith & scripture
The connection
Searching for his father's lost donkeys, Saul consults the seer Samuel, who privately pours oil on his head (1 Samuel 10:1). Saul is then chosen publicly by lot at Mizpah. Later Samuel rebukes him and declares that God has rejected him as king (1 Samuel 15), breaking their bond.
When and where
1 Samuel 9–15, at Samuel's town in the land of Zuph, at Mizpah and at Gilgal, around 1050 BC by traditional dating.
How do we know?
Known only from 1 Samuel. Anointing rulers with oil was a real Near Eastern custom: an Amarna letter (EA 51) recalls a pharaoh anointing a Syrian king.
Questions and debates
1 Samuel gives three accounts of Saul becoming king (anointing, lot, victory at Jabesh); scholars debate whether these are separate traditions stitched together.
▸Samuel, last judge and kingmaker anointed King DavidFaith & scripture
The connection
After rejecting Saul, God sends Samuel to Jesse's family in Bethlehem. Seven older sons pass by, for 'the Lord looks on the heart' (16:7). The youngest, David, is called in from the sheep and anointed, and 'the Spirit of the Lord rushed upon David'. He would wait years to rule.
When and where
1 Samuel 16:1–13, in Bethlehem, while Saul still reigned. The men of Judah, then of all Israel, anointed David again later (2 Samuel 2, 5).
How do we know?
Only the biblical text records it. Scholars note its theme of God choosing an overlooked younger son, which recurs with Jacob and Joseph.
Questions and debates
Historians debate whether the story was told to give David's takeover divine backing, since he was not Saul's heir.